Monday, August 17, 2009

Mix Compression: Two Approaches

I was on gearslutz.com and came across a very heated discussion about mixing compression on the mix bus. Someone had made a comment about not using it and it went on and on about whether you should, how you should use it, what gear or plugins you should use, and so on. I really don’t want to get into all that right now, but I will re-post what I posted on gearslutz here:

There is no one answer to whether you should use compression on your mix buss or not. Everyone has a different approach and I have gone through my own phases where I did or didn’t compress the mix. (Presently I’m off it, but I do happily compress about everything else and I’m using a slight limiter on the mix.)

I once had the honor of moderating a panel for NARAS that had Brendan O'Brien and Jimmy Douglass on it. What a treat! I threw away the questions that had been prepared for me and asked all the things I had heard rumors about and wondered myself for years. One of these was about mix compression. When asked what each of them used on their mixes Jimmy's answer was "None", Brendan's was "YES! Lots! Sometimes 2 or 3 compressors in a row".

Now I think this shows a fault in how people ask these kind of questions- or rather, the results they hope to achieve. They want to find an answer or technique that they can just plug in to their current routine to get the same results as the one that they are getting the advice from. But it is totally out of context. Whatever Jimmy is doing in other parts of his mix means he doesn't need to use comp on the buss. Brendan on the other hand is working towards using that, and I'll bet is running some sort of compression from the start.

Mixing (and production) is like cooking. There are lots of ingredients that must be added at the right time, in the right order, in the right amounts to get the right results. Yet strangely it might come out differently the next time. And someone else might cook something equally as good, but take a different route.

* * *
A few other interesting notes from that panel:
I asked both of them how long they spent mixing a song. Jimmy: 2 or 3 days. Brendan: 5 to 6 hours.
Was it true that Brendan uses the same bass guitar that he’s had for years with the same original strings on every song? (this based on a rumor I’ve heard around Atlanta from a few people) “No!”, he laughed. While he does have a favorite bass and the strings might be old (he didn’t really know when they’d been changed, so they are probably old) he doesn’t use it on everything, just when appropriate. Again, think of the context. I’ll bet there are several rock producers who heard this rumor and stopped changing their bass strings.

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

Howеνer, an individual уou cɑn foret abօut really need to get yourѕelf
employed directly into records ɑոd alsο records
formalities. Obtaining а college degree azines ѡhen tҺat is
neϲessary bt, should t mode reall distressing.
She wantѕ potential buyer tto save ɑt tɦе least 30% to ɡеt а downpayment'аs'ersus օn toƿ of througɦ an 8-10-month crisis fund secured.


mу blog sms lån

Anonymous said...

We at Flow Link Systems have been serving our valuable customers worldwide requiring high-quality castings for more than 15 Years.

Do you need to have to optimize your internet site.
Additionally, men and women have trust with your company
and merchandise when your Far better Enterprise Bureau ranking is optimistic.



Feel free to surf to my website; Rent a Serp Review and Bonus

Anonymous said...

Google "homesourcing" or "virtual assistants" to get started in your search for a real, salaried
work-at-home job. The affiliate marketing has quickly become one
of the greatest forms of the online revenue makers.
Must be a business that benefits me in the long term.


my web blog - legit work from home

Anonymous said...

You think about whether it's been a great discovery or a sad discovery.
com, the Ultimate Mobile Currency Marketplace, your one stop for all your mobile currency needs.

If you can, try to spend resources as you acquire them unless you are saving for something expensive.


My homepage :: how to get free gems in clash of clans

Anonymous said...

The best scenaгio; hіt the cardio in the morning - on an empty stomach - ɡet in a
few meals and return to the gym later in the day to build
muscle density. ComƄined with a ѕmаll waistlіne, this gives you the hourglass figure everyߋne is talking about.
On the otɦer ѕide there are low intеnsity long duration eхercises like
walking, biking, rսnning, swimming, etc.

My weblog: turbulence training pdf

Anonymous said...

This will get you traffic to your site and make money.

Then consider yourself one of the few, true internet marketers.

Efficiency: Many carriers provide multiple receive emails, so your fax messages are automatically delivered to
whomever you intend.

Also visit my homepage :: Full Report

Anonymous said...

Why users still make use of to read news papers when in this technological
world all is accessible on web?

Here is my web site ... pityriasis versicolor,pizap,polyvore,tasmy fokus powierzchnie,tasmy paktofonika,tasmy pfk powierzchnie,tasmy plotery,tasmy powierzchnie,tasmy tekst powierzchnie,tasmy tnace,tasmy tnace do drewna,tasmy tnace do pil tasmowych,tasmy tnacep,tasmy tnacess,tasmy tnacessor

Anonymous said...

This is my first time pay a visit at here and i am in fact happy to read everthing at
alone place.

My webpage :: buscar mujeres

Anonymous said...

Remarkable ideas. Studies has demonstrated that
it is productive towards appetite suppression excess fat burning up and increased vitality metabolism.
Garcinia Cambogia will be loaded with necessary vitamins, fibers, minerals and other healthy nutrition the human body
requires. Now the question will be what exactly will
be the benefits to picking out and using Garcinina?
Let's consider a closer search at Garcinia Cambogia success stories

Here is my web-site; garcinia cambogia info

Anonymous said...

hi!,I like your writing so a lot! percentage we
communicate edtra about your post on AOL? I require an expert in thiss
house too solve my problem. May bee that is you!
Looking forward to see you.

Here is my webpage - getting through depression

Anonymous said...

If photos of the scene can be taken, it's a good idea. A few points
that could help victims choose the right professional are as follows:.
Not only does one need to recover from the injury, but
in addition they have to think about different necessary costs of the injury similar
to medical expenses, lack of income, and long term medical expenses.


My webpage ... personal injury las vegas

Anonymous said...

Excellent beat ! I wish to apprentice whilst you amend
your site, how could i subscribe for a weblog website?
The account helped me a appropriate deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided vibrant clear concept

Feel free to surf to my page - green coffee weight loss

Anonymous said...

louis vuitton Handbags online
There's definately a great deal to learn about this issue.
I like all of the points you have made.

Anonymous said...

We stumbled over here by a different web address and thought I may
as well check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you.
Look forward to looking over your web page repeatedly.

Here is my blog post: Outcall Massage In London (Elgg.Melzian.Net)

Anonymous said...

Introducing score multipliers, powerups and speed bonuses demonstrates highly addictive.

Then they often take up all of the space. Microsoft
says that most you'll need to see Windows 8.

Have a look at my homepage ... whatsapp for pc

Anonymous said...

My partner and I stumbled over here coming from a different website and
thought I may as well check things out. I like what
I see so now i'm following you. Look forward to looking
at your web page repeatedly.

Here is my site; Pillole Allungamento Pene.pdf

Anonymous said...

Howdy! I could have sworn I've visited your blkog before but ater looking at some
of thee articles I realized it's new too me. Anyways, I'm certainly happy I stumbled upon it and I'll be book-marking it and checking back frequently!



Also visit my page Jetpack joyride cheats

theylee said...

navigate here replica dolabuy helpful hints i thought about this check these guys out www.dolabuy.su

tothen said...

look what i found Dolabuy Goyard Read More Here have a peek at this website visit the site resource

titool said...

useful link Ysl replica handbags read this Dolabuy Celine pop over to these guys replica bags